Hydraulic vs. Electric Winch Shootout
I just read your "Hydraulic vs. Electric Winch Shootout" in the Nov. '97 issue, and was surprised by your experience. I have had a single-speed, 10,500-pound MileMarker winch on my two-door Chevrolet Tahoe for about a year and a half, and I haven't experienced any of the problems you ran into.
I've seen electrical components and winches get fried, and while some of the damage could have been avoided using common sense and a pulley, the experiences left me looking for an alternative.
The entire installation of the hydraulic winch, including mounting a Warn Trans4mer winch mount, took about five hours at Dirty Parts in Culver City, California. No dump valve was required, and I've been able to steer while winching. While the installation of the MileMarker is definitely more complicated than that of an electric winch, I believe the result is well worth it.
Also, I disagree with Warn's assertion that hydraulic winches are not for vehicle recovery-just ask any wrecker/tow-truck operator. If I were pulling logs, fences, or something similar and the two-speed MileMarker didn't exist, I'd probably get an electric winch. If I needed to pull a 6,000-plus-pound truck up a long, steep slope, or out of deep mud, I'd take a slow but dependable hydraulic winch every time.
My only complaints about the hydraulic winch are the slow no-load speed of the single-speed model, which makes reeling in the cable after winching very time-consuming, the stiff buttons on the standard remote control (MileMarker offers a wireless remote as well), and the rigidity of the 3/8-inch cable. I've considered replacing the cable with a thinner and longer one, but every time I push the winch to the limit, I'm glad to have the heavier cable.
Finally, I too have experienced some creep when the winch is stopped with a heavy load on it, but not as much as you did during your testing. On the downside, there's no way to lock the gears in the single-speed model as you described for the two-speed model, but the winch will hold the creeped-out position without the engine running.
I'm not trying to justify or validate my purchasing decision, or dispute your experiences with the MileMarker winch, but I did want to let you know that your findings may be the exception rather than the rule. Obviously, the design of the power steering setup and the state that it's in are critical to the operation of the MileMarker winch. Another important consideration is whether the vehicle is carbureted or has EFI-a carbureted engine that stalls on a hill will make the MileMarker useless.
I just finished the great winch shootout. It seems the majority of the hydraulic-winch problems are with the power steering pump-would it be feasible to add a separate hydraulic pump to power just the winch? This would allow steering while engaging the winch. I built a wood splitter with a small pump; it puts out tremendous pressure with a 5hp engine.
Great article on the vintage Power Wagons. Not all of us have new $35,000 toys!!
Walker Lake, NV
MileMarker can supply winches tuned for use with PTO-driven pumps or electric-over-hydraulic pumps. However, MileMarker claims the standard version of its winch will work adequately with the factory power steering pump, so that's the way we tested it. For the same reason, we didn't upgrade the electrical system for use with the electric winch. We're not disputing that we could make modifications to the truck to make either winch work better. In fact, we've since learned that many people are happy with their hydraulic winch after modification to the power steering system.
I would have liked to have seen some approximate pull weights of regular vehicles in regular stuck situations. It's hard to know how much weight you're really pulling. I'm planning on installing a Ramsey 12,000-pound winch on the front of my pickup and a MileMarker 10,500 in the rear. For approximately $700 extra, I'll be running the tranny PTO to a separate hydraulic pump instead of using the power steering pump. I'll be able to pull all day long and won't burn up pumps, and the pulling capacity should be increased with the higher pressure of the PTO-driven pump. Also, I'm told MileMarker is coming out with a higher tensile-strength winch which should alleviate the twisting on the mount that you experienced.
A regular stuck situation? We reported that a dead pull up a Surprise waterfall netted a load of about 5,200 pounds.
As for your winch shootout, I find your results skewed and favorably prejudiced toward the Warn. I have owned a 9,000-pound MileMarker for more than two years. During that time many high-country four-wheelers have been glad to see it. My winch has never stalled, even under 20,000-pound loads, nor has it ever burned up a power steering pump or even the power steering fluid. It has been a constant and dependable winch.
Rather than go on and on about the attributes of a MileMarker, let's do this: Why don't you bring whatever winch you want to western Colorado and we'll go 'wheeling together. I'm about two hours from Moab, Telluride, and Ouray. The Grand Mesa, granddaddy of the flattop mountains, is also close by. We'll take a Jeep and drive it down the boat ramp on Grandby Lake No. 2 and see which winch gets it out. The last two times I tried this, it took the MileMarker and a snatch block to accomplish the job.
David Bernatis Sr.
We stand by our test as being fair and accurate. In fact, we believe it was more fair than what you've proposed since the winches in your test would be on different vehicles. By installing both winches on the same vehicle, we held constant most of the variables that affect winch performance and the load placed on the winch. In fact, we could argue that the MileMarker had an advantage since it was installed by professionals who are familiar with the product, and we bolted the Warn on in the middle of the desert. Also, we pointed out the shortcomings of both winches, and we went through great lengths to keep the MileMarker in the contest by replacing the power steering pump. Furthermore, we used a winch dyno to test true loads-we seriously doubt your ability to judge a 20,000-pound pull without such test equipment.
Submission information: 4-Wheel & Off-Road welcomes letters to the editor. Letters must include an address or a telephone number so the sender can be verified. Once verified, your name may be withheld at your request. Letters published in this magazine reflect the opinions of the writers, and we reserve the right to edit letters for clarity, brevity, or other purposes. Due to the large volume of mail we receive, we regret that we cannot reply to unpublished letters or return photos. Write to: Editor, 4-Wheel & Off-Road, 6420 Wilshire Blvd., Los Angeles, CA 90048-5515, fax 213/782-2704, e-mail firstname.lastname@example.org.