• JP Magazine
  • Dirt Sports + Off-Road
  • 4-Wheel & Off-Road
  • Four Wheeler

4x4 Of The Year Competitors - Score Card

Posted in Project Vehicles on February 1, 2005 Comment (0)
Share this

Previous 4x4 of the year winners2004 Volkswagen Touareg V-82003 Lexus GX 4702002 Jeep Grand Cherokee (4.7 HO V-8)2001 Jeep Grand Cherokee (five-speed auto transmission)2000 Toyota Tundra1999 Jeep Grand Cherokee (4.7 V-8 Limited)1998 Jeep Grand Cherokee (5.9 V-8 Limited)1997 Jeep Wrangler Sport1996 Jeep Grand Cherokee (with center diff lock)1995 Dodge Ram (2500 V-10 longbed Club Cab)1994 Dodge Ram (1500 V-8 shortbed regular cab)1993 Jeep Grand Cherokee1992 Chevrolet Blazer (fullsize)1991 Dodge Dakota1990 Nissan Pathfinder (four-door)1989 Toyota pickup1988 Jeep Cherokee (4.0 engine)1987 Nissan Pathfinder (two-door)1986 Ford Ranger1985 Isuzu Trooper II1984 Jeep Cherokee (2.8 engine)1983 Chevrolet S-10 Blazer

Test Structure

CATEGORY RANKED
HIGHEST
Ride & Drive (30% of total points)
Urban Grand Cherokee
Highway Grand Cherokee
High Speed Dirt & Gravel Tacoma
Sand Grand Cherokee
Rockcrawling Wrangler Rubicon
nHillclimbing Wrangler Rubicon
Braking Quality Grand Cherokee
Overall Grand Cherokee
Empirical (25% of total points)
Torque/Weight Ratio Grand Cherokee
11/44-mile Acceleration Grand Cherokee
60-0 Braking LR3
Load-carrying Capacity Power Wagon
nMiles Per Gallon Liberty
Price As Tested Frontier
Overall Frontier
Mechanical (25% of total points)
Engine's Available Power Grand Cherokee
Transmission Grand Cherokee
4WD/Low-range Engage Wrangler Rubicon
Steering Grand Cherokee
nFit and Finish Power Wagon
Drivetrain Performance LR3
Overall Grand Cherokee
Interior (10% of total points)
Ergonomics Grand Cherokee
nAppearance, Fit and Finish Grand Cherokee
Appointments Grand Cherokee
nPerceived Noise Level Grand Cherokee
Overall Grand Cherokee
Exterior (10% of total points)
Body Styling Power Wagon
Cargo Power Wagon
Four-wheeling Attributes Power Wagon
Fit and Finish Grand Cherokee
Overall Power Wagon

Jeep Grand Cherokee LimitedPower, traction, comfort, and versatility. Those are the four cornerstones of the coveted 4x4 of the Year award. Every vehicle that enters our annual test possesses at least one of these virtues, but the perfect off-road machine brings all of them, to every terrain, and leaves unscathed. Once a year we, the staff of the world's largest off-road magazine, gather the latest and greatest off-road vehicles that are coming to market and drag them through the most rigorous off-road test in the industry to see which ones have it and which do not.

For the seventh time in the history of our 23-year-old test the Jeep Grand Cherokee Limited has again taken home the golden ring-and-pinion gear trophy. Despite its extra heft, a change to an independent front suspension, and what must be as a philosophical switch to target a more mainstream customer, the Grand Cherokee Limited still reigns supreme over the off-road competition.

Coming into the test our judges were leery of what at first looked like a high-powered, yet watered-down, version of the former champion. The new WK just doesn't have the athletic stance of its predecessors, nor does it retain any of the suspension architecture we had come to love. At best we thought it would be a luxurious highway blaster that we hoped would work OK off-road. But when we got out on the trail and shifted the Quadra-Drive II system into low range...we knew we had a winner! The electric lockers and brake-based traction control work in harmony to squeeze every ounce of grip from the Goodyear tires. As long as we had a single wheel on the ground the new Grand pushed and pulled us through the hairiest obstacles we could find.

Unfortunately the new Grand seems to have sacrificed some of its beloved wheel travel and articulation for less body roll and more stability. It just doesn't swallow the bumps and jumps like the old solid-axle version did, and it left us longing for an Up Country suspension package with bigger tires and more shock valving. Our judges still gave the Grand high marks in the rocks, sand, and gravel, but we feel there is more capability in this platform. Until then the new Hemi-powered '05 WK is worthy of the Grand Cherokee heritage, and winner of our 2005 4x4 of the Year competition.

Comments

Connect With Us

Newsletter Sign Up

Subscribe to the Magazine

Sponsored Links